Vinyl is a bit disappointing so far.
My first thought way-back-when was that Bobby Cannavale was not a good choice for a lead - but then I tried to work with it and kinda got myself to an attitude of, okay creative inspired choice. That could definitely work.
But no, not really.
He's not the main problem though. The problem I am finding - and it also applies to Mozart in the Jungle come to think of it ---> I don't really care about anyone. I am drifting along with both shows - for now - but it would help a whole lot if you would give me a reason to pull for/against someone.
Maybe have someone be deeply moved by some ducks. That has worked before.