Mudcat
yap
- Since
- Jan 27, 2010
- Messages
- 32,603
- Score
- 436
- Tokens
- 0
My review of Boyhood (2014)
Yeah, no, not really.
This is the one that was shot over 13 years so the kids age before your eyes (as do the adults.)
It's an interesting technique (I will refrain from the word gimmick). It is ballsy and effective for what it is.
My problem - and many criticky types disagree - note that this film is currently rated 8.9 at imdb - (it will drop, I guarantee) - but to justify all those years of footage, we end up with a 2:45 movie - and just not that much happens. A bunch of family stuff. That's about it. 2 hours, 45 minutes.
The other problem for me; and it's weird because I heard critics going out of their way to say that so much could have gone wrong with this project - like the kids could have grown into bad actors. Well, in the movie I saw, the kids did grow into very mediocre actors. So a lot of the time I was not so much absorbed in the scenarios as being conscious of watching kids trying to act.
Big-time movie killer for me.
And then there was the content. There were some wonderful moments. But for every one of those, there were 3 run-of-the-mill-family-scenarios-that-have-been-done-countless-times-before-and-really?-165-minutes?
It's okay and I'm glad to have checked it out, but I sure can't imagine myself ever watching it again.
5.2 out of 10
Yeah, no, not really.
This is the one that was shot over 13 years so the kids age before your eyes (as do the adults.)
It's an interesting technique (I will refrain from the word gimmick). It is ballsy and effective for what it is.
My problem - and many criticky types disagree - note that this film is currently rated 8.9 at imdb - (it will drop, I guarantee) - but to justify all those years of footage, we end up with a 2:45 movie - and just not that much happens. A bunch of family stuff. That's about it. 2 hours, 45 minutes.
The other problem for me; and it's weird because I heard critics going out of their way to say that so much could have gone wrong with this project - like the kids could have grown into bad actors. Well, in the movie I saw, the kids did grow into very mediocre actors. So a lot of the time I was not so much absorbed in the scenarios as being conscious of watching kids trying to act.
Big-time movie killer for me.
And then there was the content. There were some wonderful moments. But for every one of those, there were 3 run-of-the-mill-family-scenarios-that-have-been-done-countless-times-before-and-really?-165-minutes?
It's okay and I'm glad to have checked it out, but I sure can't imagine myself ever watching it again.
5.2 out of 10