FairWarning
Boring Poster
- Since
- Apr 9, 2010
- Messages
- 11,466
- Score
- 531
- Tokens
- 18
The implication is that the quality of the song in and of itself is responsible for the popularity, money etc..
I would disagree. Its an interesting question however.
I would guess that millions of people could write a song of similar quality and style if they were inclined to do so. Perhaps this bands young, quirky, douchey styling and look is appealing to some aspect of the young culture. Perhaps the band has contacts etc in the industry. Perhaps they caught some break.Who knows the particulars of how all that stuff works. (this applies to any art(?) business imo).
But the point is that if some talented musicians were willing to write a song of similar quality and style (without shooting themselves) there is no expectancy that it would also become a hit. There are many other factors involved.
Pop music is marketed to the under 25 crowd. It is also a very copy-cat industry, the shelf life of a trend or style is only 12-18 months for the most part. Its probably harder getting a 2nd song/album to make it.