I'll say this about The Knick: every time I think, okay, now they're going to venture into trying-too-hard territory, they don't.
It hasn't really done anything to make me have these fears/suspicions. I think it is more about other shows I have been watching in the last little while. Halt and Catch Fire, Masters of Sex, Ray Donovan. The writers always seem to want to call attention to themselves and do tricks.
But no, The Knick: good, smooth, balanced production. Plenty of subtlety and style. Intelligent. Very well done.
I mean obviously it's a TV show so everyone has more noteworthy stuff going on than you would expect from a random sample of people. But it's not over-the-top.
Also fascinating. In the same way that Mad Men occasionally veers from all the plots/characters and just takes a look at the state of advertising at that time, the Knick gives these detailed recollections of the state of medicine at the time. Educational - and makes you glad to be living in the present.
Good show.