I don't think so.
For whatever reason it simply doesn't work. It either makes the guy providing the options look bad or the guy selecting looks bad. Either way it's not producing a winner.
I wanted to spotlight Muddy and I keep failing him. I thought it was because we approach games differently and because of that what I liked as options just didn't jive with what he see's as edge. So then I attempted to switch it up and that didn't work either.
There has been more MudPlay winners over the course of the series than GameLive Play Of The Day/Week wins though.