Is Fight Club the best movie ever?

[Mudcat]

Muddy,

How does Dumb and Dumber rate on the Mudcat scale of approval?

Great question. Any time you start asking for Mudcat movie reviews, it is a great question.

I have no rating for it recorded at imdb so I guess I haven't seen it since I started doing that. It is not fresh in my mind but going by my hazy memories, I would say about a 5. I recall a scene involving diarrhea so let's say the thumbs-up side of 5.

Again, great question.

 

[BGS 9.5]

Caddyshack II best movie ever FTW

 

[stevek173]

I'd even go so far as to say that I'd put Dumb and Dumber ahead of it.

Well when you are living a movie I do understand that it beefs up your opinion of it.

 

[stevek173]

great book, palahnuik is a pretty damn good author.

great director, fincher knows what he is doing.

bold move steve, impossible to call out the greatest movie of all time.

and the answer is FLETCH

Fletch is pretty damn good

 

[Matty]

Good movie but come on Stevie boy.

 

[Matty]

i like how they think credit card companies are the most evil people out there.

Bankers are. Banking is the root of all evil pico.

 

[Fu Manchu]

not even close. sorry.

 

[roguejuror]

I'd even go so far as to say that I'd put Dumb and Dumber ahead of it.

Well when you are living a movie I do understand that it beefs up your opinion of it.

get him monkey

 

[RobbieP]

No, Kangaroo Jack is.

 

[AMBy]

good movie...not earth shattering.

Definitely no syndedoche New york...or whatever that crappy movie that everyone here loves is called.

 

[Matty]

good movie...not earth shattering.

Definitely no syndedoche New york...or whatever that crappy movie that everyone here loves is called.

You should visit us more often Ambay.

 

[MonkeyF0cker]

get him monkey

Starting this thread alone is enough embarrassment for him I think, RJ. Besides, I'm not really concerned with what a telemarketing used car salesman might think of me.

 

[stevek173]

Starting this thread alone is enough embarrassment for him I think, RJ. Besides, I'm not really concerned with what a telemarketing used car salesman might think of me.

Bitter sux. Who likes it, right?. Also I like you I think I forgot to mention that, because we have a common cause.

Monkey - you are great here. Be good and let me be man is about it.

Peace.

 

[roguejuror]

i have always said Dumb and Dumber is the best american movie eva !!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

 

[Matty]

Stevie boy got CLOSED.

 

[stevek173]

Stevie boy got CLOSED.

That won't work.

 

[Rubyn]

Not the best movie, but certainly a good movie. I just wish people would stop casting Helena Bonham Carter.

 

[Tron]

I voted no. Impossible to name the best movie ever.


It's like trying to figure out what the best song ever is. Impossible.


I think this thread would have been much better had it read, "Fight Club is my favorite movie ever". Some tool would still come in here and tell you that it's an awful movie but then you could just say, "go fuck yourself tool, it's my favorite movie"