Matty's Ranking of American Whiskeys
Crack-like
1. Maker's 46
2. Fighting Cock
3. Maker's Mark
4. Jack Daniel's Single Barrel
5. Evan Williams White Label (Bottled-in-Bond)
6. Buffalo Trace
7. Eagle Rare Single Barrel
8. Knob Creek Rye
9. Four Roses Single Barrel
10. Elijah Craig 12 Years
Excellent
11. Booker's
12. Wild Turkey 101
13. Woodford Reserve Something or Other
14. Knob Creek Single Barrel Reserve
15. Bulleit 10
16. Knob Creek
17. Bulleit
18. Old Charter 10
19. Four Roses (yellow label, 80 proof)
20. Four Roses Small Batch
21. Old Fitzgerald's 1849
22. 1792 Ridgemont Reserve
Good
23. George Dickel Rye
24. Corner Creek
25. Jim Beam Black
26. Wild Turkey 81
27. Jack Daniel's Old No. 7
28. Gentleman Jack
29. Jefferson's
30. Jim Beam White
Bad
31. Wild Turkey 80
New addition at #5,
Evan Williams White Label (50% ABV). Amazingly rich and complex for the price (36 Canadian dollorz). I rarely sip neat bourbon these days but this thing is just calling for it. No need to tame the high ABV with water, it's perfect as is. Very impressive.
I ought to do some rearranging at the top of the list. Both Maker's Marks are due to drop a little just based on their climbing prices.
This is a value-biased list.