Matty Rain's Ranking of Scotch Whiskies
Crack-Like
1. Dalmore 18
2. Dalmore 10yo 1989
Excellent
3. Highland Park 12
4. Glenfiddich 15
5. Aberlour A'bunadh
6. Glenmorangie 12 "The Original"
7. Lagavulin 16
8. Laphroaig 10
9. Glenfiddich 21
10. Johnnie Walker Blue
11. Balvenie 12 Doublewood
12. Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban
13. The Glenlivet 15
Good
14. Auchentoshan 12
15. Macallan 12
16. Glenfiddich 12
17. Johnnie Walker Black
Bad
18. Ballantine's Finest
19. Johnnie Walker Red
Buncha new entries and some reshuffling in this latest update - Lagavulin 16 is trending up as we work on the bottle we bought. We're acquiring a taste for peaty whiskies.
Auchentoshan 12 was a bit of a disappointment, but like Glenfiddich 21, it suffered from having been tasted right after an exceptional whisky, in this case a collector's-only Dalmore 10yo 1989. Dalmore stuff tastes very bourbon-ey and they have a very intense flavor and finish. We love that shit.
Macallan 12 was disappointing, very sweet and unidimensional. Not bad at all but not something we'd buy, especially considering the unusually high price point for a 12.
Balvenie 12 Doublewood is truly excellent - like Dalmore, it has a flavor profile similar to bourbon, with the barley adding complexity. We especially enjoy the subtle woody notes. This might become my go-to affordable single malt along with Highland Park 12.